Concerning the rules for admission to the next PhD year and to the PhD final exam, the PhD Teaching Board recalls that, among the PhD objectives, and listed as the first point, is the “number and quality of scientific publications” produced (and co-produced) by the PhD student. Consequently, it is very important to create a proper structure that can be of constant help and incitement for scientific production.
In more detail, concerning the rules for admission to the next PhD year and, at the end of the third year, to the PhD final exam:
- The Research Advisor, who is not mandatory, will act together with the PhD Tutor to solicit the PhD students about their scientific production and to give constant support, both to highlight positive aspects and to advise about possible critical points. The Research Advisor, chosen by the Teaching Board on request of the PhD Tutor and/or the Coordinator, must be an expert in the scientific field and possibly, but not mandatorily, a member of the PhD Teaching Board.
- The Tutor and the Research Advisor (if any) will jointly meet the PhD student periodically (at least twice a year, as an indication) to check learning and scientific activity, highlight the obtained results, suggest possible corrections, and track future directions. As a consequence of these periodic meetings, the Tutor and the Research Advisor will produce minutes to be submitted to the PhD Coordinator and Teaching Board.
- PhD students will be requested to produce a report to send to the Tutor, Research Advisor (if any), Coordinator, and Teaching Board in the final months of each year (e.g., in September, since each PhD year ends on October 31st), structured as follows and covering all activities from the beginning of the PhD (i.e., the report at the 3rd year will cover the overall PhD):
- Description of the Research Activity (maximum 4 pages)
- Educational and Training Activity (including the official certificates of the exams)
- Followed Courses and Seminars
- Followed Schools
- Your Publications (structured into journals, magazines, book chapters, conferences)
- Followed Conferences and Workshops (both presenting and not presenting papers)
- The experience developed outside the University of Genoa during your PhD (either abroad or in Italy but not at the University of Genoa), specifying:
- Activity developed (very short)
- Period of time
- Hosting institution/industry
- Participation in Research Projects
- Project Title and Description (concise)
- Developed Activity in the Project
- Awards and Scientific Recognitions
- After presenting the mentioned report, PhD students will be requested to present their research activity to the Coordinator, the Tutor (who must produce consequent minutes, better specified in the following; in this view, this presentation may be one of the two annual meetings required between Tutor and student) and, possibly, the Research Advisor and the Teaching Board.
- As a consequence of the previous points, the decision about admission to the next year and to the final exam will be taken by the Teaching Board on the basis of:
- The report sent by the PhD student, the presentation, and the consequent Tutor minutes, which must highlight (either in words or synthetically, through evaluations such as very good, good, fair, sufficient, insufficient): the PhD student’s contribution to the research, autonomy level, originally developed ideas, interest shown, interaction skills, and overall level achieved.
- The scientific production of the PhD student, which should have the following minimum features: (I) at the end of the second PhD year, to be admitted to the third year: one scientific paper submitted for publication in an international journal/magazine/book chapter/conference, agreed with the Tutor and, if present, the Research Advisor, possibly also considering the Italian evaluation level of publications; (II) at the end of the third PhD year, to be admitted to the final exam: one scientific paper published/accepted in an international journal/magazine/book chapter/conference, agreed with the Tutor and, if present, the Research Advisor, possibly also considering the Italian evaluation level of publications.
- Concerning the final exam, at the end of the third year, the deadline to deliver the final version of your thesis is indicatively set to October 31st (the strict deadline will be communicated to the candidates). Your thesis, the report of your overall activity (see point 3), and the Tutor/Research Advisor minutes (see point 5a) will be evaluated by two external reviewers, not belonging to the University of Genoa and not participating in your PhD, indicatively by the end of the year. The reviewers will express an analytical written judgment on the thesis and will either propose admission to the public discussion (final exam), with acceptance or minor revision, or propose to postpone the exam for a period of not more than six months if they believe the thesis requires significant additions or corrections (major revision).
If you wish to request the additional title of Doctor Europaeus, you need to submit a request to the PhD Coordinator by the end of September of the last year. The request can be processed only if you have spent, with the authorization of the Teaching Board, at least 3 months of your PhD in a research institution of the European Union outside Italy, for research purposes, and if it is not the main location of your PhD.
If you are admitted to the final exam (i.e., the opinion of the PhD Teaching Board and of the two reviewers is positive), you have about one month (indicatively from the end of December to the end of January) to implement the modifications to the thesis suggested by the reviewers. The final deadline to deliver the final amended version is typically the end of January. All reported dates will be confirmed year by year. Please refer to the documents on the UniGe PhD programmes website and, in case of doubts, contact dottorato@segreterie.unige.it.
The final version of the thesis must be sent to the Coordinator and to the members of the final exam evaluation board, who will be communicated by the Coordinator. The final exam should take place before the end of February.